Skip to main content
WUHLD
← Back to articles

How to Handle Inheritance Jealousy Between Siblings

· 15 min

Note: The following scenario is fictional and used for illustration.

When David and his sister Emma were called to their solicitor's office to hear their mother's will, they expected a straightforward equal split. Instead, Emma inherited the £420,000 family home in Reading while David received £60,000 in savings—an obvious imbalance that shattered their once-close relationship.

David felt devastated and undervalued. What he didn't know was that Emma had given up her career for three years to care for their mother during her decline, a sacrifice worth roughly £105,000 in lost income. Their mother had tried to balance this in her will but never explained her reasoning to David.

Without that context, David saw only favouritism. Emma saw resentment where she expected gratitude. Two years later, they still don't speak.

This isn't uncommon. 49.5% of inheritance disputes in the UK involve siblings, making them the most common type of family conflict over estates. Inheritance disputes have risen 37% over the past decade, with unequal distribution cited as a primary cause in roughly a third of cases.

Whether you're a parent planning your estate or an adult child navigating complex family emotions, this guide provides practical strategies to preserve family harmony.

Table of Contents

Why Inheritance Triggers Jealousy Between Siblings

Inheritance jealousy isn't about greed. It's about feeling valued and treated fairly at an emotionally vulnerable moment.

Research shows that nearly 70% of financial conflicts among siblings are related to their parents. Long-standing rivalries resurface during grief, and money becomes a proxy for childhood wounds.

Sarah, 41, received £50,000 more than her brother Tom, 39. She felt guilty until the estate solicitor revealed their parents had given Tom a £50,000 house deposit ten years earlier—a gift Tom had forgotten. Without this information, the unequal inheritance would have destroyed their relationship.

In 68% of cases where unequal inheritance occurs, it's related to one sibling—usually female—taking on caring responsibilities. Without clear communication, this sacrifice breeds resentment instead of gratitude.

In the UK, parents have complete testamentary freedom. There's no legal requirement to treat children equally.

However, the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 allows certain people to challenge a will if it doesn't make reasonable financial provision.

Adult children can challenge, but the bar is high. You must prove financial need or dependency. Simply receiving less than your sibling isn't enough. Courts consider your financial resources, the estate size, and any disabilities.

In one case, a disabled adult child who received only £5,000 while a financially stable stepbrother inherited most of a £400,000+ estate successfully challenged. The court adjusted the distribution based on ongoing financial needs.

Most challenges don't succeed. Courts respect testamentary freedom unless there's clear evidence of unreasonable provision. This is why clear communication matters—most inheritance jealousy stems from lack of explanation, not unfair law.

Valid Reasons for Unequal Inheritance (And How to Justify Them)

Common justified reasons for unequal inheritance include:

Caring responsibilities: In 68% of cases where unequal inheritance occurs, it relates to one sibling providing significant care. Emma, 45, quit her job for three years to care for her mother, sacrificing approximately £105,000 in income. Her mother left her the £420,000 family home while her brother David received £60,000 in savings.

Lifetime gifts: Michael, 52, received £150,000 less than his sister Aisha, 50, because their parents paid for his private school and university education (£150,000) while Aisha attended state school.

Financial dependency: Different financial circumstances, disabilities, or support needs.

Business succession: One child runs the family business.

Reason Communication Strategy
Caring responsibilities Quantify care value (hours × local care rate)
Lifetime gifts List all significant gifts with dates and amounts
Financial dependency Explain dependency without being patronising
Business succession Explain business continuity needs
Estrangement Brief, factual explanation without inflammatory language

The critical insight: justified reasons become sources of jealousy without explanation.

The Power of a Letter of Wishes in Preventing Jealousy

A Letter of Wishes is a non-binding document explaining your reasoning. Research shows it helps prevent litigation by demonstrating why you divided assets a certain way.

An effective Letter of Wishes should include:

  • Explanations for unequal distribution
  • Quantification of lifetime gifts and care contributions
  • Any context beneficiaries might not know

Example:

"To my children David and Emma,

I've left the family home to Emma and the savings to David. Between 2020 and 2023, Emma gave up her career to care for me full-time, sacrificing approximately £105,000 in income and £8,000 in care expenses.

The family home is valued at £420,000. David's £60,000 inheritance, combined with the £50,000 house deposit we gave him in 2015, brings his total to £110,000. Emma's inheritance (£420,000) minus her sacrifices (£113,000) represents roughly £307,000.

This represents my attempt to acknowledge Emma's sacrifice while ensuring David is also provided for. I love you both equally.

With all my love, Mum"

Family disputes arise from uncertainty and perceived unfairness. A Letter of Wishes transforms potential jealousy into understanding.

Having "The Conversation" While You're Still Alive

Research shows that transparency prevents conflict. If your children will be treated differently, tell them now and explain why.

Helen, 72, and Robert, 74, called their three adult children together six months after updating their will. Eldest daughter Miriam would receive the family business (£280,000), middle son Paul the family home (£320,000), and youngest daughter Claire the investment portfolio (£340,000).

Initially, Miriam felt shortchanged. But her parents explained she'd worked in the business for 20 years at below-market salary, sacrificing £60,000. Paul had provided regular support. Claire pursued an independent career. When Helen died two years later, no disputes occurred—everyone knew what to expect and why.

Framework for the conversation:

  • Schedule dedicated time (not holiday gatherings)
  • Be specific about amounts and reasoning
  • Invite questions and listen actively
  • Validate emotions
  • Follow up in writing

What to say: "I understand this feels unfair. Let me explain my reasoning," and "I love you all equally. This decision is about circumstances, not love."

When Jealousy Has Already Started: Addressing Sibling Conflict

Early intervention can prevent permanent rifts.

For parents: Acknowledge the situation directly. Schedule individual conversations. Consider whether your will needs revision. Update your Letter of Wishes. Offer family mediation.

For adult children: Separate grief from money. Seek information before assuming. Ask the executor for explanations. Consider what you did receive—lifetime gifts, educational support, housing help. Focus on relationship preservation. Consider mediation before litigation.

Grace, 52, received £180,000 while her brother Oliver, 49, received £380,000. She felt devastated until the estate solicitor showed her that Oliver had been covering their father's care home top-up fees—£2,200 monthly for three years (£79,200 total). Understanding replaced resentment. The relationship was preserved because information replaced assumption.

The Role of Executors in Managing Sibling Jealousy

Appointing one sibling as executor often fuels jealousy. Consider a neutral executor—a professional, solicitor, or trusted family friend.

Margaret, 68, appointed her accountant James as executor rather than one of her three sons. When she died, the will revealed unequal distribution. Because James was neutral, the sons couldn't accuse each other of manipulation. He held a family meeting, explained valuations, shared the Letter of Wishes, and answered questions without favouritism.

Executor best practices:

  • Provide detailed written accounts
  • Communicate regularly with all beneficiaries
  • Share the Letter of Wishes promptly
  • Document everything
  • Offer mediation early

When to use a professional executor: History of conflict, unequal distribution, complex estates, blended families, or estrangement.

Professional executors typically charge 2-5% of estate value—often worthwhile to prevent £10,000+ in litigation costs.

99% of inheritance disputes are resolved outside court through mediation.

Resolution Method Typical Cost Timeline
Family conversation £0 Days-weeks
Mediation £500-£3,000 1-3 months
Solicitor negotiation £2,000-£8,000 3-6 months
Court litigation £10,000-£50,000+ 12+ months

Court cases lasting over 12 months increased by 518% between 2019 and 2024. Litigation is expensive and uncertain.

Adult children can challenge wills under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Requirements include: claims within six months of probate, proving you're an eligible claimant, demonstrating unreasonable provision, and showing financial need. Adult children face a higher bar than spouses.

Charlotte, 46, felt devastated when brother Benjamin, 43, inherited £220,000 more. In mediation, Benjamin revealed he'd loaned their parents £180,000 interest-free 12 years earlier. They agreed to reduce the differential by £40,000. The relationship was preserved and litigation avoided.

Equal vs. Fair: Rethinking Inheritance Distribution

Equal isn't always fair. The question is: what's fair for YOUR family?

Equal distribution makes sense where children received similar lifetime support, have similar circumstances, and no one provided extraordinary care.

But fairness often requires context:

Account for lifetime gifts: House deposits, university tuition, business investment, wedding costs.

Account for care contributions: Years of caregiving × local care rate (£15-30/hour), lost income, out-of-pocket expenses.

Account for current circumstances: Financial dependency, disability, housing security.

Example: Roberts family estate (£650,000):

Sophie, 44: No lifetime gifts. Provided 4 years full-time care (value £120,000). Single parent, renting, £35,000 salary.

Daniel, 41: Received £65,000 house deposit. Weekly visits. Married, homeowner, £68,000 salary.

"Fair" distribution: Sophie £387,500, Daniel £262,500. Equal distribution: Both £325,000.

The critical question isn't "Is this equal?" It's "Can I explain why this is fair?"

Creating Your Will to Minimise Sibling Jealousy

Jealousy-prevention checklist:

  • Create detailed Letter of Wishes - Include specific amounts, dates, and context. Explain lifetime gifts and care contributions.

  • Have family conversation - Explain your estate plan. Allow questions. Provide written summary.

  • Choose neutral executor - Consider professional executor for complex estates.

  • Account for lifetime gifts - List significant gifts with amounts and dates.

  • Be specific about assets - Include professional valuations. Specify how assets should be divided.

  • Review regularly - After major life events and every 3-5 years minimum.

Example will clause:

"I give my property at 14 Ashford Road, Bristol to my daughter Emma Jane Roberts. I acknowledge this exceeds the cash inheritance I am leaving to my son David Michael Roberts (£60,000). I explain my reasoning in a separate Letter of Wishes dated 15 March 2025, which I direct my executor to share with both Emma and David. I have attempted to balance Emma's care contributions with David's earlier receipt of a £50,000 house deposit in 2015."

Creating a clear will is the foundation of preventing inheritance disputes between siblings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What percentage of inheritance disputes involve siblings?

A: 49.5% of all inheritance disputes in the UK involve siblings, making them the most common type of family conflict over estates. Legal professionals estimate that well over 50% of parties involved in inheritance disputes are siblings. With over 10,000 will disputes reported annually, sibling conflicts represent a significant challenge for UK families.

Q: Can you give one sibling more inheritance than another in the UK?

A: Yes, parents in the UK have complete testamentary freedom to distribute their estate unequally between children. However, 32% of inheritance disputes cite unequal distribution as the primary cause. Adult children can challenge unequal inheritance under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 if they can prove they weren't reasonably provided for.

Q: How can a letter of wishes prevent inheritance jealousy?

A: A letter of wishes explains your reasoning for specific inheritance decisions, helping prevent misunderstandings that fuel jealousy. When siblings understand why you made certain choices—such as giving more to one child who provided care or less to another who received lifetime gifts—they're less likely to contest your will or feel resentful.

Q: What causes inheritance jealousy between siblings?

A: Inheritance jealousy typically stems from unequal distribution (perceived or actual), lack of communication about estate plans, long-standing sibling rivalries resurfacing during grief, and feelings of being less valued or loved. In 68% of cases where unequal inheritance occurs, it's related to one sibling (usually female) taking on caring responsibilities.

Q: Should I tell my children about their inheritance while I'm alive?

A: Yes, research shows that discussing your estate plans with your children while you're alive significantly reduces the likelihood of disputes. If children are going to be treated differently, it's important to let them know ahead of time and explain why. This transparency prevents surprises and allows you to address concerns directly.

Q: How much does it cost to resolve an inheritance dispute between siblings?

A: Inheritance disputes can cost thousands of pounds to resolve through litigation. However, 99% of inheritance disputes are resolved outside court through mediation and negotiation. Mediation typically costs significantly less than court proceedings, with some mediators basing charges on income levels. Court cases can take over a year, with probate cases lasting longer than 12 months increasing by 518% between 2019 and 2024.

Q: What is the best way to prevent inheritance jealousy between my children?

A: The most effective strategies include: creating a clear, detailed will that articulates your wishes; writing a letter of wishes explaining your decisions; having open family conversations about your estate plan; considering equal distribution or clearly justifying unequal shares; appointing a neutral executor; and regularly updating your will to reflect changing circumstances. Transparency and communication are key.

Conclusion

Key takeaways:

  • Inheritance jealousy affects 49.5% of families—you're not alone, and it's preventable
  • Transparency is your most powerful tool: clear will, Letter of Wishes, and family conversation
  • "Equal" doesn't always mean "fair"—context matters, but you must explain that context
  • Mediation resolves 99% of disputes outside court—act early, before positions harden
  • Professional guidance prevents costly mistakes—invest in clear estate planning now

Your inheritance decisions will outlive you—but so will your children's relationship with each other. The most valuable gift you can leave isn't the money itself, but the family harmony that allows your children to grieve together, support each other, and honour your memory without resentment. Take the time now to plan thoughtfully, communicate clearly, and provide the context that transforms potential jealousy into understanding.

Need Help with Your Will?

Understanding how to prevent inheritance jealousy is an important first step, but putting these strategies into practice requires a clear, legally valid will. The guidance above helps you identify potential sources of conflict and plan distributions that reflect your values while minimising family disputes.

Create your will with confidence using WUHLD's guided platform. For just £99.99, you'll get your complete will (legally binding when properly executed and witnessed) plus three expert guides. Preview your will free before paying anything—no credit card required.

Legal Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. WUHLD is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Laws and guidance change and their application depends on your circumstances. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified solicitor or regulated professional. Unless stated otherwise, information relates to England and Wales.

Sources: