Skip to main content
WUHLD
← Back to glossary

Legal Guardian vs Godparent

Also known as: Guardian Distinction, Legal vs Religious Guardian

Definition

A legal guardian is someone formally appointed in your will to care for your children with full parental responsibility, while a godparent is a ceremonial or spiritual role with no legal authority.

Many parents mistakenly believe that naming godparents at christenings or baptisms provides legal protection for their children. This dangerous misconception can have devastating consequences if both parents die without making proper arrangements.

A legal guardian is formally appointed under Section 5 of the Children Act 1989 through your will. Upon your death, the guardian assumes full parental responsibility for your children until they turn 18, making all decisions about education, healthcare, living arrangements, and finances. The appointment must be in writing and signed in the presence of two witnesses.

A godparent has no legal standing in UK law. The role is purely ceremonial or spiritual—traditionally associated with baptism ceremonies. Godparents have no automatic right to care for children if parents die and cannot make legal decisions on the child's behalf. If Emma and David name Sarah as godmother but don't appoint her as guardian in their will, Sarah has zero legal authority if both parents die.

This distinction matters because many parents wrongly assume godparents automatically become caregivers. Without a formal guardian appointment, courts decide who should care for your children, potentially placing them with someone you wouldn't have chosen. You can appoint the same person as both godparent and legal guardian, but the guardian appointment must be formalized in your will.

When Rachel and Tom appointed Rachel's sister Claire as both godmother and legal guardian in their wills, Claire could immediately assume guardianship when they died. The child went to live with the person they chose, without court intervention.

Common Questions

"Do godparents automatically become legal guardians if parents die?" No, godparents have no automatic legal rights. A godparent is a moral role, not a legal appointment. You must formally appoint them as guardian in your will.

"Can the same person be both godparent and legal guardian?" Yes, many parents appoint the same person for both roles. However, they are separate—godparent is spiritual, while guardian must be formally appointed in your will.

"What happens if I die without appointing a legal guardian?" No one has automatic legal authority. Courts decide who should care for your children, which may not be who you would have chosen.

Common Misconceptions

Myth: "If we name someone as godparent, they'll automatically look after our children if we die."

Reality: Godparents have zero legal rights or authority. Unless you formally appoint them as guardian in your will, they have no legal standing. Courts will intervene to decide guardianship, potentially choosing someone entirely different.

Myth: "We can tell godparents verbally to look after our children—we don't need a will."

Reality: Verbal agreements have no legal force. Under the Children Act 1989, guardian appointments must be in writing and witnessed by two people. Without formal appointment, courts decide based on the child's best interests—not your preferences.

  • Guardian: The parent term explaining guardian duties, qualifications, and appointment process in full detail.
  • Godparents: Explains the traditional godparent role and what godparents can and cannot do legally.
  • Parental Responsibility: The legal rights and duties guardians assume upon parents' death that godparents lack.
  • Will: The legal document where guardian appointments must be formalized, unlike ceremonial godparent designations.
  • Backup Guardians: Comprehensive protection strategy by appointing backup guardians if first-choice cannot serve.

Need Help with Your Will?

Understanding the difference between godparents and legal guardians is essential—now protect your children properly by appointing a guardian in your will. Without formal appointment, even the most devoted godparents have no legal authority to care for your children.

Create your will with confidence using WUHLD's guided platform. For just £99.99, you'll get your complete, legally binding will plus three expert guides. Preview your will free before paying anything—no credit card required.

Legal Disclaimer:

This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. WUHLD is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Laws and guidance change and their application depends on your circumstances. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified solicitor or regulated professional. Unless stated otherwise, information relates to England and Wales.