Backup Guardians UK: Why Your Will Needs a Plan B for Your Children

Rachel and Tom spent three months deciding who should be guardians for their two daughters if anything happened to them both. After countless conversations, they chose Rachel's sister Emma—a loving aunt who the girls adored.

They wrote their wills, naming Emma as guardian, and felt an enormous weight lift from their shoulders.

Two years later, Emma was diagnosed with a chronic illness that left her unable to care for herself, let alone two young children. Rachel and Tom's wills hadn't named a backup guardian.

If they died, their carefully considered plans would collapse, and a court would decide who raised their daughters—potentially placing them in temporary foster care during the legal process.

Seven out of ten UK parents have no legal guardian named in their will. Among the 30% who have made wills with guardians, many fail to name backup guardians.

This comprehensive guide explains why backup guardians are essential, who to choose, and how to structure your will to protect your children no matter what life brings.

What Are Backup Guardians and Why Do You Need Them?

Backup guardians (also called substitute or replacement guardians) are named in your will to take over if your primary guardian cannot or will not act when needed.

Under section 5 of the Children Act 1989, guardian appointments are legally valid when properly made in a will. But these appointments only take effect if your primary guardian is able and willing to accept the role.

If your primary guardian can't act, backup guardians provide a second layer of protection—preventing courts from having to appoint someone through lengthy legal proceedings.

Consider these scenarios where backup guardians become essential:

Your primary guardian dies before you
They develop a serious illness or disability
They move abroad or far from your children's community
They divorce (if you named a couple as joint guardians)
Their financial circumstances change dramatically
They change their mind about accepting the responsibility
They don't meet conditions you set in your will

The stakes are higher than many parents realize. A parent of children under 18 dies every 20 minutes in the UK—approximately 26,900 parents each year, leaving behind around 46,300 dependent children.

Without a backup guardian named in your will, a court must appoint someone through legal proceedings. This process typically takes 3-6 months, during which your children's lives are in limbo—and they may be placed in temporary foster care while the court decides.

Most parents feel "done" after making the difficult decision about primary guardians. They don't want to think about more worst-case scenarios.

But this is precisely when backup planning matters most.

What Happens If Your Primary Guardian Can't Act?

Understanding what happens when primary guardians can't fulfill their role makes the importance of backup guardians crystal clear.

Scenario 1: Your Guardian Dies Before You

Sarah named her brother James as guardian for her three children. James was 42, healthy, and eager to take on the role if needed.

Four years later, James died suddenly from a heart attack. Sarah's will still named him as the only guardian.

When guardian appointments become void due to death, they're treated as if you never named anyone at all. If you haven't updated your will with a new guardian or backup, you effectively have no guardian named.

Sarah discovered this during an estate planning review. She immediately added her sister and a close friend as backup guardians, creating multiple layers of protection.

Scenario 2: Your Guardian Refuses When the Time Comes

You cannot force anyone to be a guardian, even if they agreed years ago.

David and Emma named Emma's best friend Claire as guardian. Claire agreed enthusiastically when Emma's children were toddlers.

Ten years later, Claire's own health deteriorated, and she was caring for her elderly mother. Her circumstances had changed dramatically.

When a guardian initially accepts the role but later can't manage, they can legally refuse when the time comes. Without backup guardians named in your will, executors must apply to the court for a new guardian to be appointed—which could mean children are taken into temporary care during the legal process.

Scenario 3: Your Guardian Is Deemed Unsuitable

Courts assess guardian suitability based on the child's best interests under the Children Act 1989.

Michael named his cousin as guardian 12 years ago. Since then, his cousin developed serious addiction issues and was convicted of fraud.

Courts can refuse guardian appointments if circumstances have changed and the person is no longer suitable—even if you named them in a valid will.

This is why regular will reviews and backup guardians are both essential.

Scenario 4: Couple Guardians Separate

If you named a married couple as guardians and they later divorce, legal uncertainty follows.

Should one or both still be guardians? Which one? Without clear provisions in your will, the court must decide.

Naming backup guardians—and specifying whether couple guardians must act "jointly" (both together) or "jointly and severally" (together or separately)—prevents this confusion.

The Legal Process Without a Backup

When no suitable guardian is available, social services must assess potential carers under the Children Act 1989. Family members can apply for Residence Orders or Special Guardianship Orders.

This process takes months. During this time, children may live in temporary placements, separated from siblings, while courts make decisions.

It's a situation every loving parent wants to avoid.

Who Should You Name as Backup Guardians?

Choosing backup guardians is often harder than selecting your primary guardian because the "obvious" choice is already taken.

Start by revisiting your criteria for the primary guardian. Then ask: Who would your first choice guardians want to raise your children? Who shares similar values, parenting styles, and life circumstances?

Close Family Members

Siblings, parents (if young and healthy enough), and adult children from previous relationships make natural backup guardians.

Consider age carefully. Naming your 65-year-old mother as backup when your primary guardian is 35 might mean your backup outlives your primary choice—but age gaps matter when considering a 20-year child-raising commitment.

Close Friends

Long-standing friendships, godparents, and parents of your children's close friends who know your family well can be excellent backup guardians.

Mark and Sophie named Sophie's sister as primary guardian, with Mark's best friend Tom as backup. Tom and his wife had known Mark and Sophie for 15 years, their children were close friends, and they shared similar parenting values.

When Sophie's sister moved to Australia unexpectedly, Tom and his wife became the primary guardians in an updated will.

Red Flags to Avoid

Don't name backup guardians who:

Are significantly older than your primary guardian (they may not outlive them)
Have serious health issues
Live far from your children's school and community (unless you're comfortable with relocation)
Haven't met or don't get along with your primary guardian
Have expressed reluctance or uncertainty about the responsibility

Naming Couples as Backup Guardians

If naming a couple, specify how you want them to act:

"Jointly": Both must act together (if they separate, neither can act alone)
"Jointly and severally": They can act together or separately (provides flexibility if they separate)
"Separately": Only one is appointed (but which one if you named both?)

Best practice: Use "jointly and severally" to provide flexibility while allowing both to act together when possible.

The Family Politics Reality

Naming backup guardians might offend someone who expected to be first choice, or create tension between family branches.

Your children's welfare trumps adult feelings.

Have honest conversations. Explain your reasoning. But don't let family politics prevent you from creating comprehensive protection for your children.

Name Multiple Backups

Consider naming 2-3 backup guardians in order of preference:

"I appoint my sister Emma as guardian. If Emma is unable or unwilling to act, I appoint my brother James as substitute guardian. If James is unable or unwilling to act, I appoint my friend Sarah as substitute guardian."

This creates multiple layers of protection, dramatically reducing the chance courts need to make decisions for you.

Single Guardian vs. Couple Guardians as Backups

Whether to name a single person or a couple as backup guardians depends on your circumstances and their situation.

Benefits of Naming Couples

Anna and David named Anna's sister and her husband as backup guardians. The couple provided:

A built-in support system with shared parenting responsibilities
A two-parent household similar to what the children knew
Shared financial burden, making it more manageable
Continuity if one partner becomes ill (the other can continue)

Risks of Naming Couples

What happens if they separate? What if only one bonds with your children? What if they disagree on major parenting decisions?

These are real risks that backup provisions must address.

Benefits of Naming a Single Guardian

Clear decision-making, no risk of couple conflicts, and realistic expectations (especially if your primary guardian is also single) make single guardians simpler in some ways.

Helen, a single mother, named her sister as primary guardian and her brother as backup—both single. She felt this reflected her family structure more authentically than creating an expectation of a two-parent household.

Legal Phrasing That Matters

The words matter enormously:

Phrasing	If Couple Separates	If One Dies	If One Moves Abroad
"Jointly"	Neither can act alone	Appointment may fail	Both must act (impractical)
"Jointly and severally"	Either can act alone	Other continues	One can act while other abroad
No specification	Court decides	Court decides	Court decides

Best practice: If naming a couple, specify "jointly and severally" in your will to provide maximum flexibility while allowing both to act together when possible.

Special Note for LGBTQ+ Families

Ensure backup guardians understand and support your family structure. Consider naming backup guardians who share your values around identity, inclusion, and family diversity.

Choose people who will raise your children respecting their family history and identity—not merely tolerating it.

How to Structure Backup Guardians in Your Will

The legal language in your will determines whether backup guardians can actually step forward when needed.

The Hierarchy Structure

Structure guardian appointments in clear order of preference:

Primary guardian first: "I appoint Emma Thompson of [address] to be the guardian of my children."

Then backup guardians: "If Emma Thompson is unable or unwilling to act, I appoint James Wilson of [address] as substitute guardian."

Additional backups if desired: "If James Wilson is unable or unwilling to act, I appoint Sarah Davies of [address] as substitute guardian."

What to Include

Guardian appointments must be made in a properly executed will—signed by you and witnessed by two independent witnesses—to be legally valid under the Children Act 1989.

Always include for each guardian:

Full legal name
Full address
Date of birth (to avoid ambiguity)
Relationship to you or your children (helpful for courts)

Sample Legal Wording

Legal wording can be straightforward: "In accordance with section 5 of the Children Act 1989 I appoint [name] to be the guardian of my child, [child's name]."

For backup guardians, add: "If [primary guardian name] is unable or unwilling to act, I appoint [backup guardian name] as substitute guardian."

Adding Reasonable Conditions

You can include conditions like "provided they reside in the UK" or "provided they are under the age of 70 at the time of my death."

But excessive conditions can invalidate appointments if conditions can't be met or verified.

Avoid subjective criteria courts can't easily verify, such as "if they are still happily married" or "if they maintain their current lifestyle."

What NOT to Include

Don't make appointments conditional on factors that:

Are impossible to verify objectively
Could change between when you write your will and when you die
Create multiple backup scenarios requiring court interpretation
Impose unrealistic expectations on guardians

Keep conditions simple, verifiable, and focused on your children's welfare.

How WUHLD Handles This

WUHLD's online will platform walks you through naming primary guardians and automatically prompts you to add backup guardians with clear, legally valid phrasing that meets Children Act 1989 requirements.

You don't need legal expertise—just thoughtful consideration of who should care for your children.

What to Tell Your Backup Guardians

You've chosen backup guardians and named them in your will. Now comes the conversation.

You Must Ask First

You cannot force anyone to be a guardian. Guardian appointments only take effect if the person is willing to accept when the time comes.

Don't assume agreement—ask explicitly and get confirmation.

How to Frame the Conversation

Avoid: "You're not our first choice, but..."

Instead: "We've named Emma as primary guardian, and we'd love to have you as a backup layer of protection. You're incredibly important to us and our children, and we trust you completely to step in if circumstances change."

Frame it as what it is: essential protection, not a consolation prize.

Lucy and Nathan named Nathan's sister as primary guardian and Lucy's brother as backup. When they told Lucy's brother, they emphasized: "You're critical to our children's protection. If anything happens to Nathan's sister, we want you to be there—and even if she's able to act, we want you involved in our children's lives as their loving uncle."

Lucy's brother felt honored, not offended.

What Backup Guardians Need to Know

Share with backup guardians:

Your parenting values and priorities
Your children's routines, needs, and personalities
Financial provisions you've made (life insurance, trust funds, inheritance)
Why you chose them specifically
Your hopes for your children's education, religious or cultural upbringing
Any special needs or medical requirements

Discuss Worst-Case Scenarios

What if your primary guardian initially accepts but then realizes they can't manage? Backup guardians might be contacted sooner than expected.

What if your primary guardian can manage one child but not all three? Could backup guardians step in for some children?

These uncomfortable conversations clarify expectations and prevent confusion during an already traumatic time.

Review and Update Regularly

Schedule check-ins every 2-3 years to confirm backup guardians are still willing and able.

Life circumstances change dramatically. People move, get divorced, develop health problems, have their own children, or experience financial changes that affect their capacity to take on more responsibility.

Don't assume someone who agreed five years ago is still in the same position today.

Financial Transparency

Be honest about what financial support backup guardians would receive:

Life insurance payouts
Trust arrangements for your children
Guardian's Allowance (£22.10 per week from April 2025)
Any provisions in your estate for guardian expenses

Rachel told her backup guardian: "We have £500,000 in life insurance specifically to support whoever raises our children. That money is held in trust, but guardians can request funds for the children's needs—housing, education, daily expenses."

This transparency removed financial anxiety and helped the backup guardian commit confidently.

Special Needs Considerations

If your child has disabilities or special needs, ensure backup guardians understand:

Current care requirements and routines
Existing support systems (medical professionals, therapists, schools)
Available benefits and funding
How to access trust funds designated for special needs care

Provide detailed documentation they can refer to, not just verbal conversations.

When Primary and Backup Guardians Should Meet

Your primary and backup guardians shouldn't be strangers operating in isolation.

Why Coordination Matters

Backup guardians need to understand your primary guardian's approach. Your children need to know and feel comfortable with backups. Consistency in parenting approach reduces trauma if transitions occur.

If your primary guardian becomes gradually ill, backup guardians might need to provide increasing support before fully taking over. This requires relationship and trust.

Best Practice Timeline

Introduce backup guardians to your children within six months of naming them in your will. Maintain regular contact—at minimum annually, but quarterly or monthly is better.

Don't make backup guardians mysterious figures children meet once at a family wedding.

James and Sophie named James's brother as primary guardian and Sophie's sister as backup. They made a point of having family dinners with both guardians every few months, and their children spent holidays with each.

When James died unexpectedly (Sophie survived), the children already had strong relationships with both potential guardians. The transition, though heartbreaking, wasn't compounded by going to live with near-strangers.

What to Discuss When Guardians Meet

Primary and backup guardians should discuss:

Parenting philosophy and discipline approaches
Education priorities (public vs. private school, university expectations)
Religious or cultural upbringing
Financial management of children's inheritance
How backup guardians can support primary guardians if gradual transition needed
Children's existing relationships, friendships, and community ties

Building Children's Relationships

Backup guardians should have meaningful, ongoing relationships with your children—not just be names in a document.

Regular visits, video calls (if they live far away), attending children's events, and holiday gatherings all build bonds that could become essential if tragedy strikes.

Anna's backup guardian lived 200 miles away. They scheduled video calls every Sunday evening where the backup guardian read bedtime stories to Anna's children, and the children spent a week each summer at the backup guardian's home.

These weren't emergency preparation exercises—they were loving family relationships that happened to serve a dual purpose.

The Succession Question

Here's something most parents don't consider: your primary guardians can appoint their own successor guardians in their wills for your children.

Should you coordinate this? Should primary and backup guardians align on tertiary options?

Some parents discuss this explicitly, ensuring primary guardians would name the same backup guardian in their own wills. Others leave this to primary guardians' judgment.

There's no single right answer, but it's worth discussing.

Acknowledge the Awkwardness

These conversations can feel morbid. You're planning for your death and discussing who raises your children in tragic circumstances.

Frame it as comprehensive family planning—like life insurance, emergency contacts, or advance medical directives. It's not dwelling on tragedy; it's responsible protection.

Most guardians appreciate clarity over ambiguity when stakes this high are involved.

Updating Backup Guardians: When and How

Naming backup guardians isn't a one-time task. Life changes require updates.

Key Life Changes Requiring Review

Update your will's guardian appointments when:

You have additional children
Your primary guardian's health changes significantly
Your backup guardian's health or financial situation changes
Guardian couples divorce or separate
A guardian moves abroad or far from your family
A guardian has their own children (changing their capacity)
Your children develop special needs
A guardian develops addiction or legal issues
Your primary guardian dies

Sophie named her sister as primary guardian and her brother as backup. Ten years later, her brother developed a gambling addiction and went through bankruptcy.

Sophie immediately updated her will, naming a close friend as the new backup guardian. Uncomfortable as the decision was, her children's welfare came first.

Recommended Review Schedule

Review guardian appointments every 2-3 years minimum, or immediately after major life events.

Set a recurring calendar reminder. Treat it like renewing insurance or updating your passport—regular maintenance, not optional.

Signs Your Backup Guardian Is No Longer Suitable

Watch for:

Significant age gap has widened (backup is now 75+)
Health deterioration
Financial instability
Relationship breakdown with your family
Lifestyle changes incompatible with raising children (frequent international travel for work, substance abuse, high-conflict marriage)

Catherine's backup guardian went through a bitter divorce and started drinking heavily. Catherine felt terrible removing her from the will, but her children's stability mattered more than preserving her friend's feelings.

She had an honest conversation, updated her will, and maintained the friendship—just not the guardian appointment.

The "Guardian Ladder" Approach

When updating, consider whether your backup should move up to primary, and name a new backup.

Don't just change one name in isolation—review the entire guardian structure.

Michael's primary guardian moved to Canada. His backup guardian was willing to become primary, so Michael updated his will promoting the backup to primary and naming a new backup—maintaining layers of protection.

How to Update Legally

You must create a new will or properly executed codicil (will amendment) to change guardian appointments. You cannot change guardian appointments verbally or in a letter.

The written, witnessed will controls—not verbal conversations.

Cost and Complexity

WUHLD makes updating backup guardians simple and affordable—£49.99 for a complete new will with updated guardian appointments.

Compare this to solicitor fees of £150-300 just for amendments. When you need to update guardians, you shouldn't face financial barriers.

Don't Skip the Conversation

If you remove someone as a backup guardian, consider telling them—especially if they know they were named originally.

You don't owe lengthy justifications, but courtesy prevents confusion and hurt feelings.

"We've updated our will, and we wanted to let you know we've changed our guardian arrangements. It's not a reflection on our relationship—circumstances have just changed, and we needed to adjust our plans."

Most people understand, especially if you frame it around changed circumstances rather than personal shortcomings.

Backup Guardians and Financial Planning

Guardianship and financial planning are separate but interconnected.

Two Separate Considerations

Who raises your children (guardianship) and who manages money for your children (trustees) don't have to be the same people.

Many parents separate these roles intentionally, creating oversight and preventing conflicts of interest.

David named his sister as guardian but his brother as trustee. His sister would make day-to-day parenting decisions and request funds as needed. His brother would review requests and ensure appropriate use, protecting both the children's inheritance and the sister from accusations of misusing funds.

This separation provided checks and balances during emotionally difficult times.

Should Backup Guardians Be Trustees?

Arguments for combining roles:

Simplified management
Guardian knows children's needs intimately
Fewer people involved means fewer potential conflicts

Arguments for separating roles:

Oversight prevents conflicts of interest
Financial expertise may differ from parenting skills
Protects guardians from accusations of mismanaging funds

There's no universally right answer—it depends on your family dynamics and who you trust.

Life Insurance Calculations

Consider whether backup guardians have different financial needs than primary guardians.

If your primary guardian owns a five-bedroom house and earns £90,000, they might need less financial support than your backup guardian who rents a two-bedroom flat and earns £35,000.

Some parents specify different trust arrangements depending on which guardian ultimately raises the children, though this adds complexity to estate planning.

Guardian's Allowance

Backup guardians who take over care would be eligible for Guardian's Allowance—£22.10 per week from April 2025—if they meet eligibility criteria.

This is tax-free and paid on top of Child Benefit. It's not a large amount, but every bit helps when taking on additional children.

Special Guardianship Orders and Financial Support

Backup guardians might pursue Special Guardianship Orders (SGOs) for additional financial support from local authorities, including means-tested allowances and grants for home adaptations.

From Autumn 2025, 10 local authorities in England will pilot kinship allowances equivalent to fostering national minimum allowance rates for carers with SGOs.

Trust Fund Access

Ensure backup guardians understand how to access trust funds for your children's needs.

Provide clear documentation: who the trustees are, how to request funds, what expenses are covered, and what records must be kept.

Rebecca created a comprehensive information packet for both her primary and backup guardians that included:

Trustee contact information
Life insurance policy details
Trust fund access procedures
Children's bank account information
Documentation of existing assets designated for the children

When her primary guardian had to request funds to move to a larger house, the process was straightforward because everything was documented.

Example Scenario

Sarah left £400,000 in trust for her two children, with her sister as primary guardian and her brother as trustee.

When Sarah died, her sister took in the children. Six months later, she needed to move to a larger home to accommodate everyone. She requested £30,000 from the trust for a down payment increase.

Her brother (the trustee) reviewed the request, confirmed it was in the children's best interests, and approved the funds. The separation of roles prevented family conflict—Sarah's sister wasn't managing money and making unilateral decisions, and her brother had oversight without the day-to-day parenting burden.

This structure protected both the children's inheritance and family relationships.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I name multiple backup guardians in my will?

A: Yes. You can name 2-3 backup guardians in order of preference ("if guardian A cannot act, then guardian B; if guardian B cannot act, then guardian C"). This creates multiple layers of protection for your children.

Q: What happens if both my primary and backup guardians can't act when needed?

A: If none of your named guardians can act, the court will appoint a guardian through legal proceedings under the Children Act 1989. Family members can apply, but the process takes months. This is why naming multiple backups in order of preference is advisable.

Q: Do backup guardians have the same legal rights as primary guardians?

A: Yes. Once backup guardians assume the role because primary guardians cannot act, they have the same parental responsibility and legal rights. They're not "second-class" guardians—they have full parental authority.

Q: Can backup guardians refuse to take my children even if they're named in my will?

A: Yes. You cannot force anyone to be a guardian. Even if someone agreed when you made your will, they can legally refuse when the time comes if their circumstances have changed. This is another reason why naming multiple backups is essential.

Q: Should I name different backup guardians for each of my children?

A: Generally, no. Keeping siblings together provides stability and support during traumatic times. However, in blended families or with significant age gaps, separate guardians for different children might make sense—but this should be carefully considered with legal advice.

Q: How often should I review my backup guardian appointments?

A: Every 2-3 years minimum, and immediately after major life events (births, deaths, divorces, relocations, health changes). Set a calendar reminder to review guardian appointments as routine maintenance.

Q: Can I name someone who lives abroad as a backup guardian?

A: Yes, but you should investigate foreign legal requirements and consider appointing a UK-based substitute guardian as well. International guardianship creates additional complexity around relocation and legal jurisdiction.

Q: What if my primary guardian dies after I do but while my children are still minors?

A: Your backup guardian can step forward at that point. Your primary guardian can also appoint their own successor guardian in their will for your children. This is why coordination between primary and backup guardians is valuable.

Protecting Your Children With Complete Guardian Planning

Naming backup guardians isn't paranoid over-planning—it's essential protection for your children.

Key takeaways:

Name 2-3 backup guardians in order of preference to create multiple layers of protection
Specify whether couple guardians act "jointly and severally" to provide flexibility if they separate
Have honest conversations with backup guardians about your expectations and their willingness
Review guardian appointments every 2-3 years and after major life events
Consider separating guardianship (who raises children) from trusteeship (who manages money) for oversight

Without backup guardians, even the most carefully considered guardian plans can collapse if your primary choice can't act when needed. Courts step in, legal processes take months, and your children's futures hang in uncertainty.

You've already done the hard work of choosing primary guardians. Adding backup guardians takes just a few more minutes—and dramatically increases the protection you've created for your children.

Create your will and name backup guardians today with WUHLD. Our step-by-step platform makes it simple to name primary and backup guardians with legally valid phrasing.

For just £49.99 (vs £650+ for a solicitor), you'll get:

Your complete, legally binding will with backup guardian appointments
A 12-page Testator Guide explaining how to execute your will properly
A Witness Guide to give to your witnesses
A Complete Asset Inventory document

You can preview your entire will free before paying anything—no credit card required.

Preview Your Will Free – No Payment Required

Legal Disclaimer: This article provides general information about appointing backup guardians in UK wills and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your individual situation, please consult a qualified solicitor. WUHLD's online will service is suitable for straightforward UK estates; complex situations may require professional legal advice. Guardian appointments must be made in a properly executed will (signed and witnessed according to UK law) to be legally valid under the Children Act 1989.

Sources: