Skip to main content
WUHLD
← Back to glossary

Medical Indemnity Insurance

Also known as: Professional Indemnity, Medical Malpractice Insurance

Definition

Medical indemnity insurance is professional liability cover protecting healthcare practitioners from negligence claims, covering legal costs and compensation payments when patients allege treatment caused harm.

Understanding medical indemnity insurance is essential for doctors planning their estates, as these policies represent significant professional assets and potential liabilities that affect inheritance planning and executor responsibilities.

What Does Medical Indemnity Insurance Mean?

Medical indemnity insurance is professional liability insurance protecting healthcare professionals financially against claims of medical negligence, malpractice, or clinical errors. Under the Health Care and Associated Professions (Indemnity Arrangements) Order 2014, all regulated healthcare professionals must have adequate indemnity arrangements as a condition of registration. The GMC requires all registered doctors to maintain "adequate and appropriate insurance or indemnity" covering their full scope of practice, including legal defense costs, compensation payments, and settlement expenses when patients allege that treatment, advice, or diagnosis caused harm.

NHS employees receive state-backed indemnity through the Clinical Negligence Scheme for Trusts (CNST) for NHS work specified in their contracts at no direct cost. However, CNST doesn't cover private practice, medico-legal reports, expert witness work, teaching, research, or Good Samaritan acts outside NHS premises. This creates coverage gaps that many doctors don't realize exist until they face claims. Medical indemnity insurance differs fundamentally from Medical Defence Organisation (MDO) membership—insurance provides contractual, FCA-regulated cover with guaranteed claim acceptance, while MDOs offer discretionary support with no legal obligation to assist. Coverage limits typically range from £6 million to £15 million depending on specialty and risk profile.

For estate planning purposes, medical indemnity insurance has critical implications through tail cover (also called run-off cover). Tail cover protects your estate from claims made after retirement or death for treatment provided during your career. Because clinical negligence claims can arise up to three years from the patient's "date of knowledge" of alleged harm, potential liabilities can extend decades beyond treatment. Dr. James Chen, retiring after 35 years as a GP partner, faced a choice between £95,000 lifetime tail cover protecting his estate indefinitely or £42,000 for 10-year coverage. Without tail protection, his £1.2 million estate remained exposed to unlimited liability from historic patient claims. Similarly, Dr. Sarah Ahmed, an NHS consultant with private practice one day weekly, pays £8,500 annually for private work indemnity and must document this £180,000 business asset in her will with instructions for executors on accessing policy details and handling potential claims.

Common Questions

"Do I need medical indemnity insurance if I work for the NHS?" NHS employees are covered by state-backed indemnity (Clinical Negligence Scheme for Trusts) for NHS work only. However, you must arrange your own indemnity insurance for any private work, medico-legal reports, expert witness work, or Good Samaritan acts outside NHS premises. GMC registration requires adequate cover for all your practice.

"What's the difference between medical indemnity insurance and a Medical Defence Organisation?" Medical indemnity insurance is a regulated insurance contract with guaranteed cover, overseen by the Financial Conduct Authority. Medical Defence Organisations provide discretionary cover where acceptance of claims is at their discretion with no legal obligation to assist. Insurance offers contractual certainty; MDOs offer discretionary support.

"Does medical indemnity insurance cover regulatory hearings and inquests?" Standard medical indemnity insurance typically covers clinical negligence claims only. For GMC hearings, coroner inquests, employment disputes, and regulatory proceedings, you'll need additional medico-legal support, often provided through Medical Defence Organisations or enhanced indemnity policies. Check your policy's specific coverage carefully.

Common Misconceptions

Myth: If I work for the NHS, I'm fully covered and don't need my own insurance

Reality: NHS indemnity (CNST) only covers clinical work specified in your NHS contract. Any private work, medico-legal reports, expert witness statements, teaching, research, or Good Samaritan acts outside NHS premises are not covered. The GMC requires you to have adequate cover for your full scope of practice, meaning most NHS doctors need additional indemnity beyond state-backed arrangements.

Myth: Medical Defence Organisations are the same as insurance

Reality: MDOs (like MDU, MPS, MDDUS) provide discretionary indemnity, not contractual insurance. They can decline to support your claim at their discretion with no legal obligation to assist. Insurance provides contractual, guaranteed cover regulated by the FCA. Since the 2019 Paterson Inquiry highlighted gaps in discretionary cover, the government has recommended requiring all healthcare professionals to have FCA-regulated insurance rather than relying solely on discretionary MDO membership.

  • Medical Defence Organization: Provides discretionary cover as an alternative to contractual insurance, often covering regulatory proceedings that standard insurance excludes.
  • Clinical Negligence: The insured risk that medical indemnity insurance protects against—allegations that treatment fell below expected standards and caused patient harm.
  • GMC Registration: Requires proof of adequate indemnity arrangements covering your full scope of practice as a condition of maintaining registration.
  • Assets: Medical indemnity policies and tail cover are professional assets requiring documentation in estate planning and valuation for probate.

Need Help with Your Will?

Planning your estate as a medical professional requires careful consideration of indemnity insurance and tail cover protection. Understanding these professional liabilities ensures your executors can properly handle your medical practice assets.

Create your will with confidence using WUHLD's guided platform. For just £99.99, you'll get your complete, legally binding will plus three expert guides. Preview your will free before paying anything—no credit card required.

Legal Disclaimer:

This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. WUHLD is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Laws and guidance change and their application depends on your circumstances. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified solicitor or regulated professional. Unless stated otherwise, information relates to England and Wales.