Definition
An invalid will is a will that doesn't meet the legal requirements for validity under UK law, making it unenforceable and unable to distribute the deceased person's estate.
Understanding what makes a will invalid is critical because when a will fails legally, it's treated as if it never existed—your estate passes according to an earlier valid will, or if none exists, under intestacy rules that may bear no resemblance to your wishes.
What Does Invalid Will Mean?
Under UK law, an invalid will is one that fails to meet the strict legal requirements set out in Section 9 of the Wills Act 1837 or established by case law. The Act requires that a will must be in writing, signed by the testator in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time, with each witness then signing in the testator's presence. If any of these formalities are missing or incorrectly performed, the will may be entirely invalid. Additionally, the testator must have testamentary capacity (the mental ability to understand what they're doing, defined in Banks v Goodfellow 1870), knowledge and approval of the contents, and freedom from undue influence.
An invalid will can arise from seven main grounds: improper execution, lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud or forgery, lack of knowledge and approval, marriage or civil partnership, and intentional destruction. For example, if Sarah signs her will with only one witness instead of two, the will is automatically invalid due to improper execution. If David makes a will while suffering from advanced dementia without a capacity assessment, his will can be challenged on capacity grounds—though medical diagnosis alone doesn't automatically mean lack of capacity. If Emma writes a will then gets married, her marriage automatically revokes the previous will unless it was specifically made "in contemplation of marriage" to her spouse.
Not all invalidity is total. Section 15 of the Wills Act 1837 creates partial invalidity: if a beneficiary or their spouse acts as a witness, the will remains valid but the gift to that beneficiary fails. This is called the "purging provision." Courts also have powers under Section 20 of the Administration of Justice Act 1982 to rectify wills where there's a clerical error or the drafter failed to understand the testator's instructions—though applications must usually be made within six months of probate being granted. However, fundamental execution failures like missing witnesses cannot be rectified; the will remains invalid.
When a will is declared invalid, the consequences can be devastating. The estate doesn't follow the invalid will's instructions. Instead, it passes according to any earlier valid will, or if there isn't one, under the intestacy rules—the law's default distribution plan. Under intestacy, unmarried partners receive nothing, stepchildren aren't provided for, and charitable legacies fail. In James's case, when his partner Emma's will was invalidated by their marriage, he fortunately inherited everything under intestacy as her spouse. But if Emma had wanted to leave her vintage car to her sister or £5,000 to an animal shelter, those wishes couldn't be honored. If their estate exceeded £322,000 or Emma had children from a previous relationship, intestacy could have produced vastly different results.
Common Questions
"Can my will be invalid if I got married after I made it?" Yes, in England and Wales, marriage automatically revokes any will you made before getting married, unless the will was specifically made "in contemplation of marriage" to your spouse. Civil partnerships have the same effect. This is why newly married couples are strongly advised to make new wills immediately after their wedding.
"What happens to my estate if my will is found to be invalid?" If your will is declared invalid, your estate will be distributed according to any earlier valid will you made. If there is no earlier valid will, your estate passes under the intestacy rules—the law's default distribution plan following a strict order of relatives. Under intestacy, unmarried partners receive nothing and stepchildren aren't provided for.
"If one of my witnesses was a beneficiary in my will, does that make the whole will invalid?" No, the will itself remains valid, but under Section 15 of the Wills Act 1837, the gift to that beneficiary (or their spouse or civil partner if they were the witness) will fail. The rest of the will continues to operate normally, though this can cause problems if that beneficiary was supposed to receive a major asset.
Common Misconceptions
Myth: If there's a small mistake in my will, the whole thing is automatically invalid and worthless.
Reality: Minor errors don't automatically invalidate a will. Courts have significant powers under the Administration of Justice Act 1982 to rectify wills where there's a clerical error or failure to understand instructions, as long as the testator's intention is clear. In Ball v Ball (2017), the High Court confirmed that a mistake alone is not enough to invalidate a will. However, fundamental requirements like having two witnesses present simultaneously cannot be rectified.
Myth: Once someone dies, their will is automatically accepted and there's nothing anyone can do about it, even if it was made under suspicious circumstances.
Reality: Wills can be challenged on various grounds including lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution. Approximately 10,000 people dispute wills in England and Wales every year. Recent cases show courts will set aside wills where undue influence is proven. However, the burden of proof is high—you need substantial evidence, not just suspicion or family disagreement about fairness.
Related Terms
Understanding Invalid Will connects to these related concepts:
- Execution: The process of properly signing and witnessing a will. Improper execution is one of the most common grounds for invalidity.
- Testamentary Capacity: The mental ability required to make a valid will, defined in Banks v Goodfellow. Lack of capacity is a major ground for challenging validity.
- Witness: Two witnesses are required to attest to the will. Improper witnessing can cause total or partial invalidity.
- Revocation: The intentional cancellation of a will through destruction, a later will, or marriage. A revoked will is invalid.
- Partial Intestacy: Occurs when part of a will fails or is invalid while the rest remains valid, such as Section 15 beneficiary-witness scenarios.
Related Articles
- UK Will Requirements: Is Your Will Legally Valid?: Learn the positive requirements for will validity to ensure your will meets all legal standards and avoid invalidity issues from the start.
- What Makes a Will Invalid in the UK?: Comprehensive guide examining all grounds for will invalidity in detail with case examples, practical implications, and guidance on challenging or preventing invalidity.
- What Happens if a Beneficiary Witnesses a Will?: Understand this common cause of partial invalidity under Section 15 and how it affects gift validity without invalidating the entire will.
Need Help with Your Will?
Making sure your will is legally valid is essential for protecting your loved ones and ensuring your wishes are honored. Invalid wills cause family disputes, unexpected distributions under intestacy, and can leave the people you care about without provision.
Create your will with confidence using WUHLD's guided platform. For just £99.99, you'll get your complete, legally binding will plus three expert guides. Preview your will free before paying anything—no credit card required.
Legal Disclaimer: This glossary entry provides general information about invalid wills under UK law and does not constitute legal advice. The validity of a will depends on the specific circumstances and requires expert assessment. This information applies to England and Wales. Different rules apply in Scotland and Northern Ireland. For advice about whether a specific will is valid or invalid, or if you wish to challenge a will's validity, consult a qualified solicitor specializing in contentious probate.