Skip to main content
WUHLD
← Back to glossary

Fiduciary Duty

Also known as: Fiduciary Responsibility, Duty of Care

Definition

Fiduciary duty is the obligation for executors, trustees, and personal representatives to act with loyalty and care for beneficiaries while avoiding conflicts of interest or personal gain.

This cornerstone principle of UK estate and trust law ensures that those managing someone else's money, property, or affairs cannot abuse their position of power and must put beneficiaries' interests completely first. Understanding fiduciary duty is crucial when choosing an executor or trustee, as it defines the legal responsibilities that protect beneficiaries from mismanagement, conflicts of interest, and unauthorized use of estate or trust assets.

What Does Fiduciary Duty Mean?

Under English and Welsh law, fiduciary duty originated from the landmark case Bristol and West Building Society v Mothew (1996), where Lord Justice Millett defined it as "the obligation of loyalty." Anyone who undertakes to act for another in circumstances giving rise to trust and confidence becomes a fiduciary. This includes executors named in wills, trustees managing trusts, and administrators appointed to estates without wills. The Trustee Act 2000 and Administration of Estates Act 1925 establish that personal representatives must exercise the same degree of care as trustees, creating a statutory framework for these obligations.

Fiduciary duty encompasses several core obligations that work together. The duty of loyalty requires acting solely in beneficiaries' best interests, never your own. The no-profit rule prohibits earning unauthorized personal benefits beyond agreed executor fees or your entitlement as a beneficiary. The no-conflict rule means avoiding situations where personal interests clash with fiduciary responsibilities. The duty of good faith demands complete honesty and transparency. The duty of prudence requires managing assets with the care and skill a reasonable person would use. The duty of impartiality means treating all beneficiaries fairly according to the will or trust terms, and the duty to account requires keeping accurate records and providing information to beneficiaries.

Consider David, executor of his late father's £350,000 estate including a house. David's friend Emma offers £320,000 for the property—£30,000 below market value. Selling to Emma would be convenient and quick, but David's fiduciary duty requires getting the best price for beneficiaries, not prioritizing his convenience. Accepting the below-market offer would breach his duty of loyalty and potentially the no-conflict rule. David must obtain independent valuations, market the property properly, and achieve fair market value, or obtain all beneficiaries' informed consent to the lower price. Without proper process, beneficiaries could hold David personally liable for the £30,000 shortfall.

Similarly, consider Sarah, trustee of a trust managing £50,000 for her teenage cousins' education. Sarah owns a business needing investment capital and believes investing trust funds in her company would benefit everyone. However, this violates the no-conflict rule even if the investment might genuinely benefit beneficiaries. Sarah's personal interest in her business success conflicts with her duty to make objective investment decisions solely for beneficiaries' benefit. She must invest trust funds independently where she has no personal stake, ensuring her loyalty remains undivided.

Fiduciary duties apply equally to professional solicitors and family members serving as executors or trustees. While professionals may be held to higher standards of skill based on their expertise, the core loyalty obligations apply to everyone. An executor who is also a beneficiary—extremely common when spouses or children serve—still owes full fiduciary duties. They can receive their rightful inheritance and claim authorized fees, but must treat all beneficiaries impartially and cannot favour themselves when making discretionary decisions about estate management.

Breaching fiduciary duty carries serious consequences. An executor or trustee who breaches their duty can be held personally liable for any financial losses to the estate or trust, even if the breach was unintentional. Beneficiaries can apply to court to have the fiduciary removed from their position and replaced. Any unauthorized profit made by the fiduciary must be returned to the estate or trust. In serious cases involving fraud, theft, or deliberate misappropriation of assets, the fiduciary may face criminal prosecution. The key protection against breach is transparency—keeping detailed records, communicating openly with beneficiaries, seeking professional advice for complex decisions, and obtaining court approval when uncertain about proposed actions.

Common Questions

"What does fiduciary duty mean for an executor?" Fiduciary duty means your executor must act in the best interests of your beneficiaries with complete loyalty, honesty, and transparency. They cannot profit personally from their role beyond agreed fees, must avoid conflicts of interest, and must manage your estate with the same care a prudent person would use with their own affairs. This legal obligation ensures executors can't abuse their position of power over your estate and must always prioritize beneficiaries' financial interests over their own convenience or personal relationships.

"Can an executor who is also a beneficiary still fulfill their fiduciary duty?" Yes, an executor can be a beneficiary and still fulfill their fiduciary duty, which is very common when spouses or family members serve as executors. However, they must treat all beneficiaries impartially and cannot favour themselves over other beneficiaries when making decisions about the estate. For example, they cannot take estate assets for themselves before properly valuing everything, paying debts and taxes, and distributing to all beneficiaries according to the will's terms. The dual role requires extra care to maintain transparent records and demonstrate fair treatment of all beneficiaries.

"What happens if an executor breaches their fiduciary duty?" An executor who breaches their fiduciary duty can be held personally liable for any financial losses to the estate, even if the breach was unintentional. Beneficiaries can seek the executor's removal through court proceedings, claim compensation for losses, and require the executor to return any unauthorized profits. Courts take fiduciary breaches seriously because they involve positions of trust. In serious cases involving fraud or deliberate misappropriation, the executor may face criminal charges including theft or fraud offences under the Theft Act 1968.

Common Misconceptions

Myth: Fiduciary duty only applies to professional executors and trustees—family members don't have the same strict obligations.

Reality: Fiduciary duty applies equally to all executors and trustees, whether professional solicitors or family members. While professionals may be held to higher standards of skill and expertise based on their qualifications, the core duties of loyalty, honesty, and acting in beneficiaries' best interests apply to everyone who accepts a fiduciary role. A family executor who acts carelessly, shows favoritism, or puts their own interests first can be held personally liable just like a professional. The law recognizes no distinction in the fundamental obligation of loyalty—accepting the role creates the legal duty regardless of whether you're paid or related to the deceased.

Myth: As long as an executor acts honestly and tries their best, they can't be accused of breaching their fiduciary duty.

Reality: Good intentions don't prevent fiduciary duty breaches. An executor who honestly believes they're doing right can still breach their duty through negligence, conflicts of interest, or failing to act in beneficiaries' best interests. The law judges fiduciaries by objective standards of loyalty and prudence, not subjective beliefs. For example, selling estate property to a friend below market value breaches the duty to obtain best value for beneficiaries, regardless of good intentions.

Understanding Fiduciary Duty connects to these related concepts:

  • Executor: Executors are fiduciaries—anyone appointed as executor automatically owes fiduciary duties to beneficiaries from the moment of the testator's death, governing all their decisions throughout estate administration.
  • Trustee: Trustees are the classic example of fiduciaries, and trustee law established under the Trustee Act 2000 forms the foundation of fiduciary duty principles applied across all estate planning roles.
  • Personal Representative: This broader term covers both executors and administrators, all of whom owe identical fiduciary duties when managing a deceased person's estate under the Administration of Estates Act 1925.
  • Breach of Trust: Breach of trust occurs when a fiduciary violates their fiduciary duties, leading to potential court-ordered removal, personal liability for losses, and requirement to return unauthorized profits.
  • Duty of Loyalty: The core distinguishing component of fiduciary duty identified in Bristol v Mothew, requiring single-minded loyalty to beneficiaries and prohibiting any conflicts between duty and personal interest.
  • Duty of Prudence: Another key component requiring fiduciaries to exercise reasonable care, skill, and caution when managing estate or trust assets, holding professionals to higher standards based on their expertise.

Need Help with Your Will?

Choosing an executor who understands their fiduciary duty protects your beneficiaries from mismanagement and ensures your wishes are carried out with complete loyalty and care. Understanding these obligations helps you select the right person for this critical role.

Create your will with confidence using WUHLD's guided platform. For just £99.99, you'll get your complete, legally binding will plus three expert guides. Preview your will free before paying anything—no credit card required.

Legal Disclaimer:

This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. WUHLD is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Laws and guidance change and their application depends on your circumstances. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified solicitor or regulated professional. Unless stated otherwise, information relates to England and Wales.