Skip to main content
WUHLD
← Back to glossary

Defendant (Probate Context)

Also known as: Respondent, Opposing Party in Probate Litigation

Definition

In probate disputes, a defendant is the party being sued who must respond to legal challenges about a will's validity, estate administration, or inheritance claims.

Understanding who defendants are matters because they face strict procedural obligations with significant cost implications—executors and beneficiaries named as defendants must make strategic decisions that can affect their personal liability and the estate's value.

What Does Defendant (Probate Context) Mean?

Under Civil Procedure Rules 1998, Part 57, a defendant in probate proceedings is the party served with a claim who must respond to allegations concerning will validity, estate administration, or grant challenges. Defendants typically include executors named in the disputed will, administrators under intestacy, beneficiaries whose inheritances would be affected, or anyone with a legal interest opposing the claimant's position. This differs from standard non-contentious probate—contentious probate creates an adversarial structure with claimants bringing challenges and defendants responding.

Defendants face strict obligations under CPR Part 57 and Practice Direction 57. They must acknowledge service within 28 days of receiving the claim form, stating whether they'll contest, remain neutral, or concede. Defendants holding probate documents must lodge them with the court. Those contesting must file a formal defence. Executors have a unique option: they can adopt a neutral position by declaring they'll abide by the court's decision. This is common in Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 claims, where executors let the court decide without the estate funding an expensive defence. Unlike most civil proceedings, default judgment cannot be obtained—claimants must prove their case even if defendants don't respond.

Common scenarios include will validity challenges, Inheritance Act 1975 claims, executor removal applications, and grant revocation proceedings. Multiple defendants often appear—in Inheritance Act claims, both executors and residuary beneficiaries may be named as all have affected interests. Cost implications are substantial: losing defendants typically pay both sides' legal fees, potentially £50,000–£200,000 or more. This explains why executors frequently choose neutral positions—as long as they remain genuinely neutral, they're entitled to recover reasonable costs from the estate on an indemnity basis, protecting them from personal liability.

Common Questions

"Who can be named as a defendant in probate proceedings?" Defendants typically include executors, administrators, or beneficiaries with interests opposing the claimant's position. When someone challenges a will's validity, named executors are usually defendants because they're responsible for defending the will.

"What are a defendant's responsibilities once served with probate proceedings?" Defendants must acknowledge service within 28 days and lodge any probate documents they control. Under CPR Part 57, they must state whether they're contesting, remaining neutral, or conceding. If contesting, they must file a defence.

"Can an executor choose to remain neutral when named as a defendant?" Yes, executors can adopt a neutral position by stating they'll abide by the court's decision. This is common in Inheritance Act 1975 claims where executors acknowledge the court should decide without the estate funding an expensive defence.

Common Misconceptions

Myth: Being named as a defendant in probate proceedings means you've done something wrong or illegal.

Reality: Being a defendant simply means you're responding to someone else's legal claim—it doesn't imply wrongdoing. Executors are routinely named as defendants when wills are challenged because they're the appropriate legal parties to defend the will's validity, not because they've acted improperly.

Myth: Executors named as defendants must actively defend the will and fight the claim to fulfil their duties.

Reality: Executors can remain neutral by stating they'll abide by the court's decision. This is common in Inheritance Act 1975 claims where executors acknowledge the court should decide without the estate funding an expensive defence. Executors maintaining genuine neutrality are entitled to recover reasonable costs from the estate on an indemnity basis.

  • Contentious Probate: Disputed probate proceedings where defendants exist, contrasting with standard non-contentious administration.
  • Claimant: The opposing party bringing the legal action that defendants must respond to.
  • Caveat: Earlier-stage mechanism to stop probate that may escalate to formal proceedings with defendants.
  • Will Contest: Common contentious claim where defendants, usually executors, respond to invalidity allegations.
  • Inheritance Act 1975: Legislation governing provision claims where executors frequently adopt neutral positions.
  • What is Probate? A Step-by-Step Guide for Executors: Explains standard non-contentious probate that contrasts with contentious proceedings where defendants are named.
  • How to Contest a Will in the UK: Covers the claimant's perspective on bringing will challenges that defendants must respond to.
  • Grounds for Contesting a Will: Details the specific legal allegations defendants must defend against in validity challenges.
  • The Inheritance Act 1975 Explained: Explains the claim type where executors commonly adopt neutral defendant positions.
  • What is a Caveat and When to Use One: Covers the earlier-stage dispute mechanism before formal defendant proceedings begin.

Need Help with Your Will?

Understanding defendant roles in probate disputes highlights the importance of creating a valid, clearly drafted will that minimizes challenge risk. Properly executed wills with appropriate witnesses and clear provisions reduce the likelihood of contentious proceedings.

Create your will with confidence using WUHLD's guided platform. For just £99.99, you'll get your complete, legally binding will plus three expert guides. Preview your will free before paying anything—no credit card required.

Legal Disclaimer:

This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. WUHLD is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Laws and guidance change and their application depends on your circumstances. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified solicitor or regulated professional. Unless stated otherwise, information relates to England and Wales.